Community Feedback on FCPS’ Start Times Now Online

by Karen Goff — July 10, 2014 at 9:30 am 4 Comments

Community feedback on changing Fairfax County Public Schools start times has now been organized by FCPS and posted on its website.

The school board will get a final presentation on the four start times option at a meeting later this month.

After a 2012 decision committing to changing high school start times, FCPS paid experts at Children’s National Medical Center more than $100,000 to study the impact on lack of sleep among teens and formulate scenarios for bell changes.

What the experts found: The students were chronically sleep deprived with a 7:20 a.m. start time. Pushing high school start times past 8 a.m. would have an impact on everything from behavior to grades to driving records and sports injuries, the experts say.

“Delaying school start times is one of most important ways to help ensure adolescents are getting enough sleep,” study leader Judith Owens said at a May 27 meeting at South Lakes High School. She also said students who start school after 8 a.m. are less likely to be depressed, get better grades, score as much as 200 points higher on the SATs and may have higher future earnings.

The CNMC team formulated four scenarios for high school bells. The changes would not go into effect until fall of 2015. The proposals range from start times between 8 and 9:15 a.m., with various changes for elementary and middle school students in order to accommodate the high schoolers.

See details on all four proposals on FCPS’ website.

The proposals will cost between $2.7 million and $7.6 million to implement, mostly to purchase new buses, school board members said. Meanwhile, the FY2015 schools budget was passed this spring with less money than expected from the county board of supervisors, so FCPS had to make $97 million in cuts and will offer employees delayed step raises.

The feedback posted online is from small group discussions from meetings at eight FCPS high schools, including Reston’s South Lakes High School, in May and June. The comments concentrate on the pros and cons of each proposal.

All four options have pros and cons, the community feedback shows.

Some of the pros in community feedback: More sleep for high schoolers, obviously; Options 2 and 3 help families by having siblings home to watch younger kids in the afternoon; teachers will get more sleep; Option 4 is good because high schoolers get more sleep and elementary students will not be impacted.

Some of the general parent concerns about all options: cost of implementation; middle schoolers may get less sleep too; elementary students will be going to school in the dark; and that FCPS has not given the option of “no change” to bell schedule.

Visit FCPS’ website to see complete feedback.

Where do you stand on the proposed high school bell changes?

Photo: Group discussions at a May FCPS community meeting a South Lakes High School on high school start times.

Margaret P

If those are the options I hope they go with Option 3. It is beneficial to have my older kid available to help with getting the little ones off the bus. And #3 is the only option that allows for that. It also allows my elementary student to get the full 12 hours sleep he needs without having to go to bed at 6pm.
South Lakes Curmudgeon

None of the options has elementary kids going to school in the dark. So why is that a concern?

All of the options have later start times for middle school. So why is that a concern?

“No change” is contrary to the generally accepted science. So it shouldn’t be an option.

If Loudoun high schools can start at 9 am and be beat FCPS in academics and sports, why don’t FCPS teachers and coaches support the change?
- NPReston
  
  If you start school at 7:40 then kids need to wait at their bus stops earlier to get picked up. In December when the sunrise is at 7:20am or so, they will be in the dark.
Leslie Sogandares

Loudoun students say this is what is great about the change: “We can stay up later to study. We get to sleep in so we can stay up later.” Hmmm. Seems to me the change isn’t going to be much of a change. Here’s a thought: ask the county and teachers to schedule with greater care tests, projects, etc. Most kids will tell you that the pressures associated with ramped-up academic and athletic expectations is what keeps them from sleeping well. Before we spend money we don’t have, can we please have THAT conversation?

Subscribe to our mailing list